OrderCentraal Planbureau

Order this book about the credit crisis (only in Dutch)

Contents
Nederlands

Chapter 1. The emergence of the crisis

References [ CPB | General | Scientific ]     Summary

Authors

Michiel Bijlsma & Gijsbert Zwart
Contact: Michiel Bijlsma

In this chapter

  • Why did banks take such big risks on the US housing market?
  • Why are the old risk management solutions no longer sufficient?
  • The repackaging and reselling of mortgage loans enabled banks to sidestep existing regulations.
  • Credit rating agencies, in their role as advisor in the repackaging and reselling of financial products, have little incentive to produce a reliable risk estimate for the same products.
  • Banks act as lenders' supervisors on behalf of the investors. The reselling of the loans undermined this function.
  • Mortgages Delinquency Rates

    Fast growth securitised subprime and Alt-A mortgages

    Grafiek

    Delinquency Rates on U.S. Residential Mortgage Loans

    Grafiek
    Stop | Play

    References

    CPB

  • Centraal Economisch Plan 2009, Chapter 5, De kredietcrisis - oorzaken en gevolgen.
    Special chapter in the Central Economic Plan 2009, about the credit crisis.
  • Michiel Bijlsma and Wim Suyker, december 2008, The credit crisis and the Dutch economy... in eight frequently asked questions, CPB memorandum 210.
    The answers to eight important questions about the credit crisis.
  • General

  • Casey Serin, Wikipedia-article.
    How Casey Serin attempted to make his fortune through 'flipping' in California, until the bubble burst.
  • Michiel Bijlsma, Albert van der Horst and Suzanne Kok, De kredietcrisis - oorzaken, gevolgen en beleid, Tijdschrift voor Politieke Economie, 2009, 3(1), pp. 48-67.
    About the causes and consequences of the credit crisis.
  • Susan Pulliam, Serena Ng and Randall Smith, 2008, Merrill Lynch strains to get house in order, Wall Street Journal 16 april.
    About the corporate culture of merchant bank Merrill Lynch, where bankers built up extensive portfolios of high-risk mortgage products and where risk management turned out to take second place to the realisation of short-term profits.
  • Coen Teulings, Lans Bovenberg and Harry van Dalen, 2005, De cirkel van goede intenties, Amsterdam University Press.
    This book deals with the economics of government interference.
  • Scientific

  • IMF, October 2008, Global Financial Stability Report.
    A comprehensive description of the run-up to the crisis, with a great deal of data on prices, risks and the structure of financial markets.
  • Charles Calomiris, 2008, The subprime turmoil: what’s old, what’s new, and what’s next?, Lecture at the Jackson Hole symposium.
    An overview of the development of the credit crunch, the similarities with earlier bank crises, the role of government policy in the emergence of the crisis and the US's policy response to the crisis.
  • Anil K. Kashyap, Raghuran G. Rajan and Jeremy C. Stein, 2008, Rethinking capital regulation, Jackson Hole.
    Analysis of the causes of the crisis. The authors present a type of disaster insurance for banks as a possible alternative to the costly increase of capital requirements.
  • Raghuram Rajan, 2005, Has Financial development made the world riskier?, Jackson Hole.
    Forward-looking analysis of the developments on financial markets and the risks they brought with them. The article sketches a worst-case scenario that reveals many similarities with the current crisis.
  • Gary Gorton, 2008, The panic of 2007, Lecture at the Jackson Hole symposium.
    A comprehensive description of how subprime mortgages were packaged, portioned and resold, and how this contributed to the bursting of the bubble.
  • Martin Hellwig, 2008, Systemic Risk in the Financial Sector: An Analysis of the Subprime-Mortgage Financial Crisis, Jelle Zijlstralezing.
    An analysis of the causes of the subprime crisis, its spread and the possible solutions from a policy perspective.
  • Jean Tirole, 1994, On banking and intermediation, European Economic Review 38, Joseph Schumpeter lecture, pp 469-487.
    Who supervises the supervisor? Problems relating to the corporate governance of banks and regulation as a solution to these issues.
  • Joseph Stiglitz, 2001, Information and the change in the paradigm in economics, Nobel lecture.
    Introduction to the asymmetries of information theory.
  • Coen Teulings, Lans Bovenberg and Harry van Dalen, 2003, De calculus van het publieke belang, Kenniscentrum voor Ordeningsvraagstukken.
    A Dutch summary of the theory on the economic concepts of moral danger, adverse selection and the problems associated with free riding.
  • Jean Tirole, 2001, Corporate Governance, Presidential Address for the Econometric Society, 1998, Econometrica 69(1), pp 1-35.
    An analysis of the role of shareholders and creditors as management's supervisors.
  • Douglas W. Diamond en Philip H. Dybvig, 1983, Bank runs, deposit insurance and liquidity, Journal of Political Economy, 91(3), pp 401-419.
    Classic article exploring bank runs and the role of deposit guarantees.
  • Arnoud Boot and Anjan Thakor, 2009, The accelerating integration of banks and markets and its implications for regulation, in: The Oxford handbook of banking.
    An analysis of the changes in the financial sector, the role of credit rating agencies and the implications for regulation.
  • Sanford J. Grossman and Joseph E. Stiglitz, 1980, On the Impossibility of Informationally Efficient Markets, The American Economic Review, Vol. 70, No. 3 (Jun., 1980), pp. 393-408.
    A classic article that explains why not all information is contained in the price. If all information was contained in the price no-one would have an incentive to gather any new information.
  • Ilja Segal, 1999, Contracting with externalities, The Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol. 114, No. 2. (May, 1999), pp. 337-388.
    This article explains why the incentives for contracted parties to behave well are smaller when there are many principals (clients).
  • Patrick Bolton, Xavier Freixas, and Joel Shapiro, 2008, The Credit Ratings Game, NBER Working Paper No. 14712.
    This paper shows that rating agencies have an incentive to adjust their risk assessments for the benefit of their customers.
  • Emmanuel Fahri, Josh Lerner, and Jean Tirole, 2008, Fear of Rejection? Tiered Certification and Transparency, NBER Working Paper No. 14457.
    Model-based analysis of the impact of competition on the accuracy and the transparency of the assessment of rating agencies.

  • Summary

    This chapter investigates the origin of the financial crisis. Investors in a firm want to make sure that the firm's management uses their money prudently. This usually requires someone to monitor management's activities. But monitoring suffers from a free-rider problem: each investor prefers the other investors to carry out this monitoring task. Banks are the market's solution to free-riding in monitoring by functioning as delegated monitors to investors. On behalf of their depositors, banks make sure that firms behave properly. Banks only have an incentive to do so if they have their own capital at stake as well. Capital regulation makes sure they do.

    Financial innovation, in particular the ability to offload loan risks from their own balance sheets to market investors, offered banks a convenient way to absorb the savings glut that originated from global imbalances and loose monetary policy. But this innovation, the so-called originate-and-distribute model, had two adverse consequences. First, it reduced the stake that banks retained in the loans they originated. This undermined banks' incentive to adequately monitor borrowers. Second, the innovation allowed banks to take on more risk outside the scope of regulation.

    Banks’ business was increasingly to originate loans, repackage them into securities with a well defined credit risk, which could then be sold to investors with sufficient appetite for such risks. As a result, cheap credit and banks willingness to originate increasing amounts of mortgages fuelled the housing boom in the U.S. When the housing market in the U.S. started to deteriorate, investors discovered that credit rating agencies had severely underestimated the risks involved in these securitised subprime mortgages. Again due to free-riding, a deal’s originator, instead of the investors who bought the deal, paid the rating agencies for their services.

    Up

    Contents

    • Ch 1: The emergence of the crisis
    • Ch 2: How a small problem became a big one
    • Ch 3: Global trade in reverse gear
    • Ch 4: Temporary crisis, permanent damage?
    • Ch 5: The housing market during the crisis
    • Ch 6: Try and try again on the labour market
    • Ch 7: Throwing caution to the wind!
    • Ch 8: Who bears the pension loss?
    • Ch 9: Keeping banks in check
    • Ch 10: Credit crisis and climate crisis: the one doesn't resolve the other
    • Ch 11: How painful is the crisis?
    • Ch 12: Learning from the crisis

    Next chapter >
    Copyright 2009 CPB. Sitemap - Contact.