OrderCentraal Planbureau

Order this book about the credit crisis (only in Dutch)

Contents
Nederlands

Chapter 4. Temporary crisis, permanent damage?

References [ CPB | General | Scientific ]     Summary

Authors

Peter Broer, Adam Elbourne, Bert Smid & Nick Zubanov
Contact: Peter Broer

In this chapter

  • Financial crises are nothing new. What can we learn from past crises?
  • Unemployment is on the rise. How long will this last and will we ever see a return to the former level?
  • To what extent will the credit crunch inflict permanent damage on production and employment?
  • National debt has risen dramatically. The effect of the credit crisis on state finances will remain visible for some time.
  • Previous crises GDP-loss Unemployment

    Effects of systemic financial crises on gdp per capita

    Grafiek

    GDP-loss after crisis large and longlasting

    Grafiek

    After crises in Sweden and Finland unemployment remained high for a long period

    Grafiek
    Stop | Play

    References

    CPB

  • CPB, 2009, De kredietcrisis, oorzaken en gevolgen, Chapter 5 in the Centraal Economisch Plan.
    The figures in chapter 4 on the long-term effects of earlier crises are based on an analysis contained in the Centraal Economisch Plan 2009 (see p. 138 onwards).
  • General

  • Interview with Kenneth Rogoff, 13 March 2009.
    Rogoff discusses the economic prospects.
  • John K. Galbraith, 1954, The Great Crash, 1929.
    A description of the stock market crash of 1929, which sparked the Great Depression of the 1930s. Galbraith's first bestseller, with humorous descriptions of the behaviour of speculators on the stock market. Numerous salient parallels with the current stock market crisis.
  • Charles P. Kindleberger and Robert Z. Aliber, 2005, Manias, Panics and Crashes, Palgrave MacMillan.
    A summary of crashes over the centuries. With anecdotes; without clichés.
  • Lessons there to be learnt from Finland's bank crisis, 2008, Interview with Pylkkönen, 12 September.
    Economist Pylkkönen looks back at the Finnish crisis of 1991.
  • Paul Krugman, 2008, The Return of Depression Economics and the Crisis of 2008, Allen Lane.
    A revised and extended edition of the first publication from 1999. "Told ya so," Krugman says in an interview.
  • Damage assessment, 2009, The Economist, 14 May.
    The Economist assesses the damage of the current crisis on the growth potential of the US.
  • IMF, April 2009, World Economic Outlook: Crisis and Recovery.
    In chapter 3, the IMF explores the potential for recovery in view of the global nature of the crisis.
  • Ministerie van Financiën, 2008, Miljoenennota 2009.
    The national debt has not been this low since 1814, cheered the Budget Memorandum.
  • Blogs
  • Greg Mankiw, Harvard University.
    Mankiw believes a recovery is unlikely because major shocks could have lasting effects.
  • Paul Krugman, Princeton University.
    Krugman disagrees with Mankiw and foresees rapid growth after the crisis.
  • Brad de Long, Berkeley.
    DeLong supports Krugman with empirical material.
  • Scientific


    Previous crises
  • Gerard Caprio and Daniela Klingebiel, 2003, Episodes of Systemic and Borderline Financial Crises.
    World Bank economists compare 114 financial crises since 1974.
  • Carmen M. Reinhart and Kenneth S. Rogoff, 2008, This time is different: a panoramic view of eight centuries of financial crises, NBER working paper nr 13882.
    In 1340, England's King Edward III was no longer able to repay his debts to Italy. Financial crises are nothing new. This paper outlines eight centuries of financial crises.
  • Carmen M. Reinhart and Kenneth S. Rogoff, 2009, The Aftermath of Financial Crises, American Economic Review 99(2), pp 466-472.
    The consequences of 15 major financial crises are explored. They have serious, long-lasting effects on production and employment.
  • Yuriy Gorodnichenko, Enrique G. Mendoza and Linda L. Tesar, 2008, The Finnish great depression, From Russia with love, NBER working paper no 14874.
    The sharp fall in trade with the Soviet Union plunged the Finnish economy into a deep crisis in 1991.
  • Peter Englund, 1999, The Swedish Banking Crisis: Roots and Consequences, Oxford Review of Economic Policy, vol. 15(3), pp 80-97.
    This article analyses the Swedish banking crisis of 1990. The government saved the financial system by issuing a full guarantee on banks' obligations. The total cost of the rescue operation came to an estimated 2% of GDP.
  • Temporary or permanent
  • Coen Teulings and Nick Zubanov, 2009 November, Is Economic Recovery a Myth? Robust Estimation of Impulse Responses CPB, Discussion Paper 131.

  • Xiaoming Cai and Wouter Den Haan, 2009 October, Predicting recoveries and the importance of using enough information, CEPR, Discussion Paper 7508.
    The authors argue that slightly "richer" models, that allow the effects of recessions to be both persistent and transitory, predict recoveries much better.
  • Valerie Cerra and Sweta Chaman Saxena, 2008, Growth Dynamics: The Myth of Economic Recovery, American Economic Review 98(1), pp 439-457.
    The authors look at the economic growth of a large number of countries after a crisis and conclude that countries do not revert to the prior GDP trend.
  • Council of Economic Advisers, 2009, Economic Projections and the Budget Outlook, 28 February.
    The CEA argues that recessions are followed by above-average growth.
  • John Y. Campbell and N. Gregory Mankiw, 1987, Are Output Fluctuations Transitory?, Quarterly Journal of Economics 102(4), pp 857-880.
    According to this paper, a negative shock of one percent leads to an economic decline of more than one percent.
  • Charles R. Nelson and Charles R. Plosser, 1982, Trends and random walks in macroeconomic time series: Some evidence and implications, Journal of Monetary Economics 10(2), pp 139-162.
    Influential 'Two Charlies paper' that sparked a debate on the question of whether shocks could have long-term effects. Provides a brief historical summary.
  • Why is the damage so extensive?
  • Gregory de Walque, Olivier Pierrard and Abdelaziz Rouabah, 2009, Financial Instability, Supervision and Liquidity Injections: A Dynamic General Equilibrium Approach, CEPR Discussion Paper 7202.
    This article analyses the interaction between the banking sector and the rest of the economy where there is a chance that banks go bankrupt. The article discusses various policy options for government to restore financial stability in such cases.
  • Robert Barro, Emi Nakamura, Jón Steinsson and José Ursua, 2009, Crises and Recovery in an Empirical Model of Consumption Disasters, mimeo, Columbia University.
    This article provides a statistical analysis of the frequency of rare, large, financial crises and the impact of these crises on interest rates and equity returns.
  • Ben Bernanke, Mark Gertler and Simon Gilchrist, The Financial Accelerator in a Quantitative Business Cycle Framework, Hoofdstuk 21 in J. B. Taylor en M. Woodford, Handbook of Macroeconomics, vol. 1, deel 3, Elsevier.
    This document addresses the role of credit markets in fluctuations in economic activity. The article concentrates on the impact of credit constraints in the transmission and amplification of economic shocks.
  • Paul M. Romer, 1990, Endogenous technical change, Journal of Political Economy, 98(5), pp S71-S107.
    This article discusses the idea that technological knowledge is a special type of good, which in principle can be used by everyone simultaneously.
  • Robert E. Lucas Jr, 1993, Making a Miracle, Econometrica 61(2), pp 251-272.
    Lucas uses the construction of a specific type of cargo ship during World War II as an example to demonstrate that experience gained in the workplace (learning-by-doing) is important for productivity.
  • Consequences of the current crisis
  • IMF, 2009, Sustaining the Recovery, World Economic Outlook, October
    In chapter 4 the IMF writes about the consequences of the current crisis for the economy. The fund concludes that, on average, there is no return to the pre-crisis trend after banking crises.
  • Europese Commissie, 2009, Economic crisis in Europe: causes, consequences and responses, European Economy 7/2009
    The European Commission elaborates on the causes and consequences of the credit crisis. Model simulations show that the permanent loss may be in the order of 2 to 4% in Europe.
  • OECD, 2009, The effect of financial crises on potential output: new empirical evidence from OECD countries.
    The OECD estimate of the permanent loss is about 3% for OECD countries.

  • Who is who

  • Paul R. Krugman (1953) is an economist at Princeton and columnist for the New York Times. His most important contributions have been in trade theory, economic geography and international finance. He was awarded the Nobel prize for economics in 2008 “for his analysis of trade patterns and location of economic activity.”

  • Robert E. Lucas, Jr. (1937) is an economist at the University of Chicago. His most important contributions have been in macroeconomics, especially in how economists model expectations. He was awarded the Nobel prize for economics in 1995 “for having developed and applied the hypothesis of rational expectations, and thereby having transformed macroeconomic analysis and deepened our understanding of economic policy.”

  • N. Gregory Mankiw (1958) is an economist at Harvard University. He has published many articles on macroeconomic issues such as the sources of price rigidity. He has laso written two of the most popular economics textbooks used today. Between 2003 and 2005 he was Chairman of President Bush’s council of economic advisors.

  • Charles R. Nelson (1942) is an economist at the University of Washington. His most important work has been on statistical methods and their application macroeoconomic data.

  • Charles I. Plosser (1948) is the president of the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia. Prior to joining the Philadelphia Fed he was an economist at the University of Rochester. His main contributions have been in business cycle analysis.

  • Carmen M. Reinhart (1955) is an economist at the University of Maryland. Her main contributions to economics have been in studying financial crises and exchange rate regimes.

  • Kenneth S. Rogoff (1953) is an economist at Harvard University. His main contributions have been in international finance and is the co-author of a widely used advanced level textbook on international macroeconomics.

  • James J. Heckman (1944) is an economist at the University of Chicago. His most important contributions have been in statistical analysis. He has also made important contributions to the field of labour economics. He was awarded the Nobel prize for economics in 2000 “for his development of theory and methods for analyzing selective samples.”

  • Paul M. Romer (1955) is an economist at Stanford University. His most important work has been on the theory of economic growth, specifically the processes that lead to gradual improvements in technology over time.


  • Summary

    The credit crisis is likely to have negative effects on the economy long after the initial problems with the banks have been solved. Economists know this because there have been many financial crises in the past and these have often had long-lasting effects. For example, even ten years after the end of a crisis, incomes are lower than they were expected to have been without the crisis and unemployment is markedly higher than when the crisis started. Although economists know that long-term effects are likely, their exact size is not known. The severity of the long-lasting effects is currently the subject of a fierce debate amongst prominent economists.

    This chapter discusses several possible explanations for the long-term effects of financial crises. It argues that the effects are likely due to a combination of two causes. First, a reduction in R&D efforts, as a result of higher capital costs and lower growth prospects, leads to a slackening in the pace of technical progress. Second, the severity of the recession leads to a boost in unemployed and skill loss among workers. Low-skilled workers are more likely to remain unemployment and, if employed, are less productive. Additionally, the global character of the current crisis will delay recovery, as export-led growth is not a way out.

    A look at the possible prospects for the Netherlands in the coming years contrasts with the positive outlook we had just a year ago. A highly visible long-term effect of the crisis is the structural deterioration in the government finances. The efforts of recent governments to reduce the national debt are likely to be undone without additional policy changes.

    Up

    Contents

    • Ch 1: The emergence of the crisis
    • Ch 2: How a small problem became a big one
    • Ch 3: Global trade in reverse gear
    • Ch 4: Temporary crisis, permanent damage?
    • Ch 5: The housing market during the crisis
    • Ch 6: Try and try again on the labour market
    • Ch 7: Throwing caution to the wind!
    • Ch 8: Who bears the pension loss?
    • Ch 9: Keeping banks in check
    • Ch 10: Credit crisis and climate crisis: the one doesn't resolve the other
    • Ch 11: How painful is the crisis?
    • Ch 12: Learning from the crisis

    < Previous chapter
    Next chapter >
    Copyright 2009 CPB. Sitemap - Contact.